Tuesday, 10 August 2010 22:12

The Post-Postmodern Heroics of Robert Harrison- Or, How to Put Girth in Your Quadrants

Written by 

In the first few months since the birth of this site, we've been carefully driving stakes into the ground while consciously tending the soil for our next iteration of growth into the larger world. Our aim is to organize a diverse community from various segments of society, people with talent, sincerity and grit. People also who have an intuition of a larger purpose and through whom we can leverage intelligence from various fields of study and action to better serve the needs of the world.

As you may have noticed, many of us draw inspiration from the philosopher Ken Wilber. By extension, we have loose affiliation with the community of practitioners that have emerged around his work. There are several bright lights in this widening circle.

But recently a colleague made an important general point about those drawn to Ken’s work. She observed how the community tends to be heady, interested in maps and big pictures, but somewhat lacking in the rigorous study of other fields. She evoked thebig brain image of a ‘T’. We liked that image because it reflects a single body. In this case, a skinny body with a wide head. In this community, there is a tendency for over-generalizing based on the maps of integral theory. There is not enough ‘girth’: knowledge about and practice in the diverse fields that comprise societies. The poetry of the world, if you will.

To an extent this is understandable. James Crittendon in his introduction to one of Ken’s books insightfully recognized that most people see the world through the lens of their area of expertise and tend to consider their work to be the lynchpin of truth in the universe. Used properly, Wilber’s integral map is humbling as it arranges fields and theories within a larger picture. In some ways, this will never be properly reconciled, as experts from all fields will debate and struggle to understand how to organize and privilege material properly. And this is healthy.

But it’s bothered us, this lack of girth, since our continued explicit purpose on this site is to seek the most authentic and mature human expressions within the highest context of spirit-in-action.

Happily, we’ve found one such expression. For several years, Stanford professor of Italian Literature, Robert Harrison, has hosted a campus radio program called Entitledrobert Opinions (free on Itunes). Unapologetically erudite (some might say elitist, to which we suspect he would have few qualms), the show visits a range of topics, usually focussed around an important thinker, philosopher or artist. His tastes are startlingly eclectic: from an unmatched grounding in Dante to an almost adolescent reverence for The Doors. But all the while, he weaves a graceful narrative, seeing the many faces of dante_and_beatricedivinity within the broad expressions of humanity. Always respectful of his guest’s expertise, he nevertheless remains an active and present interviewer determined to use whatever topic is being discussed to deepen the sensibilities of his audience.

His is a knowledge that demonstrates the value of being at once alert to the progressive movements of the day while remaining steeped in the principles of antiquity, and alive to the intelligence of subsequent ages. Girth to us looks and sounds not just like rhetorical appreciation for the stages through which humanity has passed, but a deep knowledge of these stages and a living recognition of their relationships past, present and future. To both know and appreciate ancient greeks runningpractices of antiquity, the relationship of sport to the human condition, the value of religious institutions, the liberation of the individual during the Enlightenment, and the progress of egalitarian principles in recent times. And to be aware and wary of the war within the soul of man, the misuses of power in traditional structures, the greed and degradation of nature in the modern mindset, and the danger of relativism to our understanding of the sacred. We’ve heard all of these themes on Entitled Opinions, always articulated with more grace than this article can muster.

To be sure, Harrison is guilty of Crittenton’s lynchpin theory. His is a bias to literature, and the themes that move through the great works of classical and contemporary literaturewriting. But to be fair, literature is among the oldest and most developed mediums, likely a better candidate for meaning making than behavioral psychology, say, or market-based capitalism.

Below fellow Beams writer Trevor Malkinson gives his own reflections and suggests a list of good episodes to start with. We’ve tried to collect a list that demonstrates the range and depth mentioned above. In his intelligence and sensitivity to the divine, Harrison is, if not a post-postmodern hero, among the wisdom elders of this emerging age.
 
~~~~~~
(Beams contributor Trevor Malkinson)
 
It’s hard to overestimate the riches to be found in Robert Harrison’s radio show Entitled Opinions. Harrison’s breadth of knowledge, and his ability to weave multiple disciplines into the delicate tapestry of his mind, never ceases to amaze me. I’m always shocked by how consistently he’s praised by his expert guests for his own ‘layman’ summary of the topic being discussed. Who is this guy? How does he do it? How does he hold Dantearistotle papyrus and Heidegger, the natural world and the political realm, the spiritual and poetic, the psychological and the cosmic in such a clear, complex, grand and exceedingly elegant narrative? Well, however he’s done it, his show is a boon and a gift and I’m sure grateful he’s on the air.

As Juma discussed, Ken Wilber’s integral map is an admirable and helpful attempt to meta-integrate many disparate disciplines of knowledge, and it can provide a clarity of orientation that’s at once illuminating and highly practical. But if we only come to know the map- and not the deep flesh that it outlines- our wisdom and understanding can remain but a thin and anemic skeleton of the mind. Wilber himself delved into all those disciplines in the course of his research, and underwent deep spiritual and psychological practice, but few of us have the time for such a colossal project. Harrison’s show can help us bridge this gap.

Memorizing the integral map, we can speak of the transition from the purple meme to egyptian agriculturethe blue meme (or from hunter-gatherer societies to agrarian ones), but how did that actually look in real time. Listen to Harrison’s two-part show on The Origins of Agriculture, and a vast and detailed portrait of that period comes alive. We can locate on the integral map the ‘kosmic address’ of the existentialist stage of camusdevelopment, but in what detail do we really understand the trials and depths of that troubled developmental location. Harrison’s shows on Heidegger, Nietzsche, Sartre, Camus and Bataille are rich and accessible introductions to that evolutionary moment.

On Harrison’s show we can both dig into history- Byzantine, Greek, Roman- and deepen our understanding of globalization, the Internet, corporations, human rights and many other features of our 21st century world. We can plunge into the treasures of the arts and of literature, and we can also learn about cancer, institutions and the fate of the earth. Harrison is a natural hubble 99integralist. The world, earth and cosmos are a single unfolding story, and he’s interested. Nay, he’s passionately interested.

Harrison resonates deeply with many of the giant critics of the modern world (and more than aptly communicates their message), but is no simple leftist or cynic. He understands and upholds the spiritual dimension of life, but is no crass fundamentalist. Harrison is a deeply moral man, an enlightened Epicurean whose voice turns and curls with the poetic taste of life going down sweetly. The world is magic in Harrison’s hands, and I for one can’t get enough of his exquisite monologues. He’s an inspiration and exemplar of what the integrated life can be. He puts girth in my quadrants.

Related items

Join the Discussion

Commenting Policy

Beams and Struts employs commenting guidelines that we expect all readers to bear in mind when commenting at the site. Please take a moment to read them before posting - Beams and Struts Commenting Policy

3 comments

  • Comment Link Jim Warren Monday, 16 August 2010 15:35 posted by Jim Warren

    This is a great write-up on Harrison, but how could you forget to post a link to his website? Or did I just miss it?

  • Comment Link Trevor Malkinson Monday, 16 August 2010 16:47 posted by Trevor Malkinson

    Thanks Jim, yes, the first link is the one that says "free on iTunes" in the first paragraph introducing Harrison. The second link is to his actual website, and that's at the beginning of the paragraph starting the second section. Glad you mentioned something, hopefully that'll be clear for future readers. Cheers!

  • Comment Link John Driscoll Monday, 16 August 2010 22:24 posted by John Driscoll

    Harrison's shows pulls us back and reminds us of the simple joys of humanistic studies, classic books and great writing. He is one of the best interviewers on the planet, demonstrating an intense familiarity with his subjects and the work of his guests. His eclectic mix of modern and ancient punctuated by bon mots and foreign phrases keeps us coming back for more. The Quintessential Renaissance Man and a pretty decent guitar player to boot.

Login to post comments

Search Beams

Newest Discussions

Twitter

"Could Not Retrieve any Tweets"