Saturday, 31 March 2012 04:36

Bruce Springsteen: The Anti-Integralist

Written by 

For me, ultimately, the most powerful examples of integral theory in action are the people that don't use all of the terminology or the insider speak or give in to the name dropping or book referencing or any of that stuff. I mean, it's all fine and it's all got it's place somewhere, I suppose. It's good to be well-read and there are -- in its better moments -- some really amazing and intelligent and compassionate people that are part of the larger integral community.

But when the rubber hits the road, I often find myself thinking, "Stop talking about it and just do it already." The strongest advocates are the people who act in an integrally informed fashion because that's just where they are in their guts.

So it was with that in mind that I found myself watching the video of Bruce Springsteen's keynote address to this years SXSW Festival with rapt attention. If what I've said above resonates with you, you need to watch this video. If you have an interest in the evolutionary story of music and the ways in which our ideas about the developmental impulse play out in perhaps our most ubiquitous art form, you need to watch this video.

If you just like Bruce Springsteen, you need to watch this fucking video. You get the idea.

Of course, the entire video isn't available for embedding, but below is a clip of the last five minutes to give you a taste:

The whole video is viewable here. The section that most got my attention was this:

So as the records that my music was initially released on give way to a cloud of ones and zeroes, and as I carry my entire record collection since I was thirteen in my breast pocket, I'd like to talk about the one thing that's been consistent over the years, the genesis and power of creativity, the power of the songwriter, or let's say, composer, or just creator. So whether you're making dance music, Americana, rap music, electronica, it's all about how you are putting what you do together. The elements you're using don't matter. Purity of human expression and experience is not confined to guitars, to tubes, to turntables, to microchips. There is no right way, no pure way, of doing it. There's just doing it.

We live in a post–authentic world. And today authenticity is a house of mirrors. It's all just what you're bringing when the lights go down. It's your teachers, your influences, your personal history; and at the end of the day, it's the power and purpose of your music that still matters.

A full transcript of the speech is available at Rolling Stone.

"Stay hard, stay hungry, and stay alive." Words to live by from a man who knows of where he speaks.

Related items

Join the Discussion

Commenting Policy

Beams and Struts employs commenting guidelines that we expect all readers to bear in mind when commenting at the site. Please take a moment to read them before posting - Beams and Struts Commenting Policy

8 comments

  • Comment Link James Barrow Saturday, 31 March 2012 19:02 posted by James Barrow

    Hi Scott
    Just wanted to say how much these comments resonate with me:
    "I often find myself thinking,"Stop talking about it and just do it already." The strongest advocates are the people who act in an integrally informed fashion because that's just where they are in their guts."

    Bruce embodies it, been doing it since 1980 at least - please check out this old speech/story/performance (not quite so meta but inspiring nonetheless):
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kxN0y7Wq2fM

  • Comment Link Mark Monday, 02 April 2012 15:56 posted by Mark

    I watched Mr. Springsteen's address in its entirety. He has enormous respect for, and knowledge of, where he has come from, and a brilliant but simple vision for the future: "There's just doing it".

  • Comment Link Scott Payne Monday, 02 April 2012 16:47 posted by Scott Payne

    James, thanks for the comment. My apologies for the delay in responding, I needed some time to unplug yesterday.

    Glad what I wrote resonated with you. It was a bit polemic in form. That was intentional on my part. I have a lot of respect for the folks who are steeped in the knowledge of these theories. And that respect probably didn't shine through in what I wrote. That is especially true for writers on this site.

    However, I do think we've come to a point where we need to steel ourselves and more substantially embrace a praxis/practice of our ideas. I think that to some degree a full realization of what "integral" means is impossible without the experience of the unexpected hiccups and warts of theory in action. And the best place to take that practice is out there -- to the rest of the world -- not huddled in our own pockets.

    At least, that's my take and how I endeavour to direct myself vis-a-vis integral theory.

    Mark, yes, the simplicity of the message and the very grounded and down-to-earth nature of Springsteen's delivery is entirely what caught me (aside from being a Springsteen fan) about this speech. Was there any particular section that caught your ear?

  • Comment Link Trevor Malkinson Monday, 02 April 2012 17:58 posted by Trevor Malkinson

    James, just gotta say that the Springsteen clip you posted has been one of my favorites for years. So good. For those who haven't watched it yet, there's also a second speech beginning at 3:51 that shouldn't be missed.

    This post also reminds of an interview that Jian Ghomeshi did with Van Morrison on CBC Radio (I just tried to find a link to it on the web, was unsuccessful). When Van was asked about what it takes to make great music, he replied, "You just get up and sing". Just get up there and sing". There was something so deceptively brilliant and direct about that statement. He mocked U2 with their 22 trucks with them on their mega-tour. Not at all necessary according to Van. You just need to get up and sing, pour your heart into it. Or as Bruce says, "at the end of the day, it's the power and purpose of your music that still matters". Amen to that.

  • Comment Link Mark Monday, 02 April 2012 18:31 posted by Mark

    I found myself riveted for the entire 54 minutes (or whatever it was). But the reverence he showed morphing We Gotta Get Out of This Place into Badlands was just, well, irreverent and entirely makes your point.

    Eric Burdon appeared with Bruce later at SXSW. Here is the link to the clip.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkBN6NWw1Cs

  • Comment Link Scott Payne Monday, 02 April 2012 18:51 posted by Scott Payne

    That was a great moment, Mark. I thought the degree to which Bruce made the form his own by peppering the whole thing with a bunch of swearing was an interesting move. One doesn't generally see a lot of swearing in keynote speeches.

    But the whole thing was just Bruce up there being Bruce and the irreverence of his delivery is part and parcel of the intelligence he presented. The authenticity of that presentation added a value to the overall offering, I thought. Very real, very as-it-is. Take it or leave it

    There is a germ of the appeal and truth that rock 'n roll itself has that resides squarely in Bruce's soul in that regard. Challenging and yet at its best wholly unpretentious about it. "This is just how it fucking is, man. What you do about that is up to you."

    I think the story that Trevor relays above about Van Morrison making fun of U2 for their audacious stage set up is a fair telling of the degree to which U2 misses that spirit, despite hitting other elements of what it means to be true artists in a whole hearted fashion.

  • Comment Link James Barrow Monday, 02 April 2012 21:33 posted by James Barrow

    Hi Scott
    You mention "the degree to which U2 misses that spirit, despite hitting other elements of what it means to be true artists in a whole hearted fashion."
    I really like U2 but I have to agree with you - they get it and they don't get it at the same time. Or more accurately, they embody it some of the time.

    I think one of the greatest songs of recent times is U2s ONE. But the original studio version outshines any live version I've seen so far. I remember reading an interview with Bono where he recounted listening back to the final mix of ONE in the studio and the band just looking at each other going "Whoa, what did we just do?"

    But I always get the sense that Bono's ego gets in the way when he's onstage .... there's always too much of a sense of "regardez moi" to let the depth come through. But let's not be too harsh - ONE stil gets me everytime though :-)

    "We're One but we're not the same,
    We get to carry each other..."

  • Comment Link Patrick Monday, 09 April 2012 19:39 posted by Patrick

    I loved thé whole 53 minutes. In the end he says that one should keep two opposite ideas in once head. If it doesn't drive you wild, then it will make you stronger.

    A beatifull adress.

    Thanks,
    Patrick

Login to post comments

Search Beams

Newest Discussions

Twitter

Loading...

Last 10 tweets from beamsandstruts:

People talking about '@beamsandstruts':